Let's Chat

When You Can’t Compete on Salary, Compete on Story: Attracting and Keeping Nonprofit Talent

Last Updated: October 15, 2026
Beth Meiklejohn

As a nonprofit, you have a powerful mission. You have passion. 

What you don’t always have is a salary budget that can go toe-to-toe with the for-profit world.

And you’re not alone. In a National Council of Nonprofits survey, nearly three out of four nonprofits reported job vacancies, and 72.2% said salary competition affects their ability to recruit and keep people.

So how do you attract great people when pay can’t be the draw? 

You give them something else to say yes to. And in most cases, that something is already happening inside your organization every single day. It just isn’t being shown.

The Right Candidates Want Proof of Impact

Here’s the good news for nonprofits: the people you want are looking for exactly what you offer.

Glassdoor research found that 79% of adults consider a company’s mission and purpose before applying, and 73% wouldn’t apply unless the company’s values align with their own. Deloitte’s 2025 global survey of Gen Z and millennials found that roughly nine in 10 consider purpose important to their job satisfaction.

But a mission statement isn’t proof. Candidates want to see the impact for themselves, and they go looking in the same places everyone else does. Pew found that 92% of U.S. teens use YouTube, more than any other platform, and Zety’s survey found that 76% of Gen Z use Instagram for career-related content. The same survey found that 46% have landed a job or internship through TikTok.

And what do they want to see? Zety found the content most likely to make Gen Z apply was company achievements (62%), workplace culture (61%), and employee day-in-the-life videos (50%). For a nonprofit, that’s your impact, your people, and your daily work. You already have all three.

The interest is there. The question is whether they find your story when they go looking.

Here’s the hard part: you have no visibility into any of it. 

Those steps happen before anyone contacts you. If your online presence is quiet, or full of event photos and donation asks but nothing about the people doing the work, a great candidate can’t tell whether you’re the real deal. No application. No email. Just a quiet scroll, and then they’re gone.

What Storytelling Shows That a Salary Can’t

A job post tells people what the job is. A story shows them why it matters.

The pay, the hours, the requirements – those all have their place. But they can’t show a candidate what it feels like to be part of your work. Storytelling can. 

And when salary isn’t your strongest card, feeling is how you win.

When a nonprofit shares its story through social and video, it gives the mission a face and a heartbeat. That looks like:

  • Impact stories that follow one person, one family, or one community from the moment they found you to where they are now.
  • Staff and volunteer spotlights that put faces and voices behind the work, and explain why they chose this path.
  • Day-in-the-life content that shows what a real day looks like, from the morning huddle to the last goodnight.

The details matter, too. A team member kneeling to meet a child at eye level. A coworker covering for another without being asked. A room full of people celebrating a small win together. The moments that tell a candidate: here, your work will matter, and so will you.

All of it is told with the consent and dignity of the people at the center of it. The best nonprofit stories honor the people in them rather than using them.

That’s the trade a great candidate is weighing. Maybe it isn’t the biggest paycheck. But it can be the work they’ll be proudest of. A story is how they see that before they say yes. (And it’s often the moment a candidate stops browsing and starts applying.)

Your Current Team Is Watching, Too

Recruiting gets the attention, but keeping good people may matter even more. Replacing an employee can cost anywhere from half to twice their annual salary. For a nonprofit, that’s money that could have gone to the mission. And the National Council of Nonprofits found that stress and burnout were cited by half of nonprofits as a factor in their workforce shortages. When one person leaves, their work lands on the people who stay.

Culture is a big part of why people stick around. In a Glassdoor survey, nearly two in three employees said company culture is one of the main reasons they stay in their job.

The same stories that attract new hires speak to the people already on your team. Mission-driven work can be heavy. Sometimes the day-to-day grind makes it hard to remember the difference you make. When a case manager sees the family they helped featured, or a program coordinator sees their team celebrated, it reminds them why they signed up. It’s appreciation your budget can afford, and in a lot of cases it’s the kind that means the most.

And no, this doesn’t mean turning every staff member into an influencer or putting someone on camera who doesn’t want to be there. People can be as involved as they want. Some will love the spotlight. Others will be just as proud to see their team’s impact honored. Either way, the culture is on display – and your people feel it.

Show Your Future Team Members Your Story, Mission, and Impact

If attracting and keeping great people is one of your biggest challenges, start by asking what your organization looks like from the outside. Does it show the impact you make, the people who make it happen, and the culture they get to be part of? Or does it show nothing at all?

Your best candidates are already looking. Give them something worth finding.

This is the work we love doing at TwoRoads: helping nonprofits tell the story of the difference they make and the people behind it. If you’re ready to show future hires (and your current team) why your work is worth choosing, we’re here. Let’s chat!

Sources